If you want to be a good baseball player, you need a good baseball first baseman’s mitt. You’ll use this mitt for 99% of all plays, so it’s important to get one that fits you, your playing style and your budget.
You can spend anywhere from $15 to upwards of $300 for a first baseman’s mitt, so picking the right one for you can be a challenge. To help you figure out which one is the best option for you, we’ve rounded up the best baseball first basemans mitts.
Our Editor’s Best Baseball First Basemans Mitts Reviews
- EASY BREAK IN: The soft synthetic leather material is lightweight and responsive making the glove easy and quick to break in so it will be game-ready in no time for baseball, softball, or teeball
- CONTOUR FIT SYSTEM: Customizable thumb-adjustment technology engineered to expand or tighten to help achieve the perfect snug fit to accommodate all players
- DURABLILITY: Crafted of a thick, premium synthetic leather designed to mimic the performance and durability of a true leather mitt without the long break-in period
- HAND FORMED POCKET: The hand formed pocket provides maximum comfort and responsive feel for making scoops and catches without drops
- NOTE: Left Hand Throw glove = worn on right hand to throw with left; Right Hand Throw = glove worn on left hand to throw with right
- DESIGNED FOR SELECT YOUTH BASEBALL PLAYERS | Ages 8-14
- GAME-READY | Soft, durable all-leather shell designed to play with right away
- IMPACT PROTECTION | Reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop for coverage and comfort
- BREAK IN | 80% Factory 20% Player
- RIGHT HAND THROW | Glove to be worn on left hand for right hand throwers
- GAME-READY | Soft, durable all-leather shell designed to play with right away
- PRO PATTERNS | Glove models trusted by MLB stars to help you feel and play like a pro
- IMPACT PROTECTION | Reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop for coverage and comfort
- COMFORTABLE FIT | Padded fingerback lining for a soft, comfortable feel
- BUILT FOR SMALLER HANDS | ContoUR fit specially designed to give you more control and a better feel
- DESIGNED FOR ADULT BASEBALL / SOFTBALL PLAYERS | Perfect for Adults playing recreational baseball or softball
- GAME-READY | Leather shell palm for pro-feel and added durability and shape retention
- IMPACT PROTECTION | Cushioned palm and index finger pads for added comfort
- BREAK IN | 90% Factory 10% Player
- RIGHT HAND THROW | Glove to be worn on left hand for right hand throwers
- BUILT FOR VERSATILE PLAYERS | The Rawlings R9 Series is designed for select youth baseball players, high school athletes, and anyone looking for a dependable glove for competitive games or casual throw-arounds.
- GAME-READY LEATHER | Soft, durable all-leather shell offers a quick break-in so players can hit the field with confidence right away.
- COMFORT-FIRST DESIGN | Reinforced palm pad, padded thumb loop, and padded fingerback liners work together to deliver a comfortable, secure fit every time you take the field.
- TRUSTED PATTERNS, BUILT TO PERFORM | Crafted with pro-style patterns that support proper fundamentals and positioning across all levels of play.
- MULTIPLE COLORS & SIZES AVAILABLE | Now available in a wider range of styles and bold new colors—because elite performance should look good, too.
- PRO PLAYER DESIGNS | Inspired by gameday gloves of MLB stars
- PERFECT FIT | Youth Pro Taper fit features smaller hand opening and lowered finger stalls
- LIGHTWEIGHT DESIGN | Making it easy for players to close and control
- LEARN THE GAME | Great performance and feel for those mastering their craft
- BREAK IN | 90% Factory 10% Player
- Wilson 2024 Baseball Classics Series A2000 1679 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Blonde/Black
- Pro Stock Leather: preferred for its rugged durability and unmatched feel; Comfort Pro Fit: Featuring our ProLux Leather, the liner of the redesigned A2000 has a richer, softer feel against your hand. The all-new Comfort Sleeve is the finishing touch, concealing the binding in the wrist for more comfort than ever before.
- Rolled Dual Welting: Dual Welting in Wilson gloves goes beyond a mere cosmetic effect, as it’s integrated into the liner of each infield, outfield and pitcher's model, offering better support and helping your glove hold its shape better over time.
- Flat Finger Binding: gives players who prefer to play with a finger outside the glove greater comfort and control in the field. By reducing the amount of space between your finger and the back of the glove, you’ll experience less pain when making plays
- DriLex Wrist Lining: Keeps your hand dry and comfortable on the field and behind the dish; Bold Logos: Bold logos strip away the distractions, allowing outlined, eye-catching Wilson logos to announce a new era in the iconic story of Wilson Ball Gloves.
- Wilson Spring 2025 A2000 1677 12.5” Baseball First Base Mitt - Left Hand Throw, Blonde/Red/Sky Blue
- Pro Stock Leather: Pro Stock Leather is preferred for its rugged durability and unmatched feel
- Rolled Dual Welting: Dual Welting in Wilson gloves goes beyond a mere cosmetic effect, as it’s integrated into the liner of each infield, outfield and pitcher's model, offering better support and helping your glove hold its shape better over time.
- Flat Finger Binding: Flat Finger Binding gives players who prefer to play with a finger outside the glove greater comfort and control in the field. By reducing the amount of space between your finger and the back of the glove, you’ll experience less pain when making plays
- DriLex Wrist Lining: Keeps your hand dry and comfortable on the field and behind the dish
- DESIGNED FOR SELECT YOUTH BASEBALL PLAYERS | Ages 8-14
- GAME-READY | Soft, durable all-leather shell designed to play with right away
- IMPACT PROTECTION | Reinforced palm pad and padded thumb loop for coverage and comfort
- BREAK IN | 80% Factory 20% Player
- LEFT HAND THROW | Glove to be worn on right hand for left hand throwers
Best Baseball First Basemans Mitts Buying Guide
Before choosing the best baseball first baseman’s mitt you should consider following options:
1. Proper Fit: Whether you are buying a new glove or simply replacing an old one, the first thing you should do is make sure it fits properly.
A glove that is either too big or too small will not give you the best performance. So, make sure you get the right fit.
If you have a friend who is into baseball, you can ask him/her to help you get the right fit. If not, you can follow some of the simple guidelines given below:
a. If the glove is too big for you, you will not be able to close the glove easily.
b. If the glove is too small for you, you will not be able to catch the ball properly.
c. The thumb section of your glove should be pointing towards your body.
d. Your palm should be able to fit in the glove with a slight bit of room for your hand.
e. The webbing of your glove should lie flat on the ground.
f. The pocket of your glove should be deep enough, so you can catch the ball.
g. The glove should be neither too stiff nor too soft.
h. The leather should be broken in well.
2. The Right Brand: There are many brands in the market today, but the most famous ones are Rawlings and Wilson. You can go for either of the two.
3. Quality of Leather: The quality of leather is another important thing to look for. You should check how thick the leather is.
You can do this by seeing the thickness of the stitches. The thicker the stitches, the higher the quality of the leather.
Another way of checking the quality of the leather is to feel the leather. If it is smooth, it means the leather is of good quality.
A smooth leather will break in nicely, giving you better performance. Also, the higher the quality of the leather, the longer the glove will last.
4. The Craftsmanship: The overall craftsmanship of the glove is also an important factor.
A well-crafted glove will have a smooth leather and will break in nicely. It will also have a good pocket.
You can check the overall craftsmanship by looking at the stitches. If the stitches are well-made and maintained, the glove is of good quality.
You can also check the stitches by feeling them. If they are smooth, the glove is well-crafted.
The stitches also tell you about the quality of the leather. If the stitches are thick, it means the leather is thick. If the stitches are thin, it means the leather is thin.
What else you should know about baseball first basemans mitts
1. What are the differences between a baseball first basemans mitt and a regular baseball glove?
A baseball first basemans mitt is larger than a regular baseball glove. It is also designed to be worn on the right hand, rather than the left hand.
2. How do you break in a baseball first basemans mitt?
You can break in a baseball first basemans mitt by playing catch with it, oiling it, and working the glove.
3. What size baseball first basemans mitt should you buy?
The size of baseball first basemans mitt you should buy depends on the size of your hand. If you have a small hand, you should buy a small mitt. If you have a large hand, you should buy a large mitt.
4. How do you care for a baseball first basemans mitt?
First basemen’s gloves are typically larger than other gloves to help them catch balls thrown in the dirt. To care for a first basemen’s glove, regularly oil it with a leather conditioner to keep it soft and pliable.
5. What are the best baseball first basemans mitts on the market?
There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on personal preferences. However, some of the best baseball first basemans mitts on the market include the Wilson A2000, the Rawlings Heart of the Hide, and the Mizuno Pro.
Conclusion
On the market, there are numerous best baseball first basemans mitts. Hopefully, the list of the top ten best baseball first basemans mitts will save you time researching and deciding on the best one for you.