• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
etcly

Etcly

Everything That Matters

  • Lifestyle
  • Health
  • Food
  • Celebrity News
  • Pet
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Reviews / Best Peanut Butter Cookies

Best Peanut Butter Cookies

You can’t go wrong with classic peanut butter cookies, but we decided to do some research to find the best one for you. We rounded up all the best products and put them to the test to find the top picks. No matter your preference for classic, crunchy, or chewy, we found the best peanut butter cookies for you.

Read on to learn more about our favorite peanut butter cookies.

# Preview Product Price
1 Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; Single Pack of Cookies (10.5oz) Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; Single Pack of... Buy on Amazon
2 Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 10) Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 10) $14.99Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
3 David's Cookies 2lbs Peanut Butter Fresh Baked Cookies - Delectable & Premium Ingredients - No Added Preservatives Cookie Gift Basket David's Cookies 2lbs Peanut Butter Fresh Baked Cookies - Delectable & Premium Ingredients - No Added... $32.95Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
4 Back to Nature - Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich Cookies - Made with Real Ingredients like Wheat Flower & Whole Grains - Seriously Tasty Snack - Non-GMO - 5.5 Ounce Back to Nature - Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich Cookies - Made with Real Ingredients like Wheat Flower... $5.49Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
5 David's Cookies Peanut Butter Chunk Fresh-Baked Decadent Cookie Gift Basket Tin — Luscious Large Peanut Butter Cookies With No Added Preservatives — All-Natural Cookies — Ideal Gift for Corporate Birthday Fathers Mothers Day Get Well and Other Special Occasions - 2 lb (8 Cookies) David's Cookies Peanut Butter Chunk Fresh-Baked Decadent Cookie Gift Basket Tin — Luscious Large... $33.95Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
6 Lance Sandwich Cookies, Nekot Peanut Butter, 10 Individually Wrapped Packs, 6 Sandwiches Each Lance Sandwich Cookies, Nekot Peanut Butter, 10 Individually Wrapped Packs, 6 Sandwiches Each $3.99Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
7 Amazon Grocery, Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 1 Lb (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary) Amazon Grocery, Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 1 Lb (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary) Buy on Amazon
8 FITCRUNCH Snack Size Protein Bars, 6-Layer Baked Bar, 1g of Sugar, Gluten Free & Soft Cake Core (9 Bars, Peanut Butter Cookie) FITCRUNCH Snack Size Protein Bars, 6-Layer Baked Bar, 1g of Sugar, Gluten Free & Soft Cake Core (9... $17.59Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon
9 Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 16g Plant Protein, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4 Ounce Cookie (Pack of 12) Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 16g Plant Protein, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4... $21.99Amazon Prime Buy on Amazon

Our Editor’s Best Peanut Butter Cookies Reviews

Bestseller No. 1
Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; Single Pack of Cookies (10.5oz)
Matt's Bakery | Peanut Butter Cookies | Soft-Baked, Non-GMO, All-Natural Ingredients; Single Pack of Cookies (10.5oz)
  • CHEWY, NUTTY & SCRUMPTIOUS - Our peanuts are made the old-fashioned way – Southern peanuts, slow-roasted until they’re perfectly crunchy. Our peanut butter contains two simple ingredients: peanuts and salt. We blend them to produce naturally delicious peanut butter cookies that’ll blow you away.
  • THE REAL STUFF - We start with all-natural ingredients just like you’d find at home. We have been using real ingredients since the very beginning. Next, we bake the cookies with care in ovens that, for over 30 years, have delivered a perfectly soft texture.
  • BACK TO BASICS - Since 1979, our mission has always been to make the best tasting cookie around. That’s why we do things a little bit different than the big guys. Non-GMO and Kosher Pas Yisroel we, like you, care about what we put in our bodies.
  • TASTE THE DIFFERENCE - When you read our ingredient list, you can pronounce everything on it. Compare our ingredients vs. the big guys and you’ll see a big difference. But taste our cookies next to theirs and the difference will be deliciously clear. Matt’s cookies are better tasting, naturally.
  • FROM THE HOME AND HEART - Every single one of our cookies is baked daily in small batches in Wheeling, Illinois to ensure that our promise of no artificial anything is achieved. No factory floors or conveyor belts here, just sweet treats from our home to yours.
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 2
Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 10)
Grandma's Cookies, Peanut Butter, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 10)
  • Includes 10 individual packs of Grandmas's Big Peanut Butter Cookies
  • Every Grandma's treat is baked with love
  • Go to your happy place with every bite
  • Great for portion control & snacking on the go
  • The only thing better than one delicious GRANDMA'S cookie is another.
$14.99 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 3
David's Cookies 2lbs Peanut Butter Fresh Baked Cookies - Delectable & Premium Ingredients - No Added Preservatives Cookie Gift Basket
David's Cookies 2lbs Peanut Butter Fresh Baked Cookies - Delectable & Premium Ingredients - No Added Preservatives Cookie Gift Basket
  • Gift pack contains: David’s Cookies Peanut Butter Cookie Gift Tin contains two dozen freshly soft-baked cookies.
  • Freshly Baked: The cookies are baked fresh, giving them a soft and chewy texture that's irresistible. This freshness not only contributes to the superior taste but also ensures that customers receive a product that lives up to their expectations of quality.
  • No Artificial Ingredients: These cookies are made with all natural ingredients and no added preservatives, so they are a healthy snack.
  • Great Gift: This gift tin makes a great gift for birthdays, holidays, or any special occasion.
  • Made in the USA: These delicious cookies are baked fresh in the USA using traditional baking methods.
$32.95 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 4
Back to Nature - Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich Cookies - Made with Real Ingredients like Wheat Flower & Whole Grains - Seriously Tasty Snack - Non-GMO - 5.5 Ounce
Back to Nature - Peanut Butter Creme Sandwich Cookies - Made with Real Ingredients like Wheat Flower & Whole Grains - Seriously Tasty Snack - Non-GMO - 5.5 Ounce
  • SERIOUSLY TASTY SIMPLE SNACKS: We believe in simply made natural snacks with no artificial flavors or colors. Our products are plant-based with no hydrogenated oils or high fructose corn syrup. You can enjoy great tasting wholesome snacks with no regrets.
  • PEOPLE LOVE OUR COOKIES: Enjoy the sweet peanut buttery taste and crunchy creamy texture of your favorite classic cookies, with a better-for-you twist! Ditch the unhealthy packaged snacks for a no-regrets, light and fun cookie.
  • EASY GOING SNACKING: Our Peanut Butter Creme Cookies offer a wholesome, great tasting alternative to the typical packaged snacks. Enjoy them dunked in milk, alongside a bowl of ice cream, or straight from the box!
  • FILL YOUR PANTRY WITH BACK TO NATURE: We strive to share nostalgic snacks made with honest-to-goodness ingredients. We offer super tasty remakes of America's classic snacks with dozens of flavors! Try our crackers, cookies, granola, or nut mixes.
  • CALIFORNIA ROOTS SINCE 1960: Our mission began in the warm & sunny Golden State where we captured that easy breezy, natural, and healthy state of mind. We think natural tastes better so our super tasty snacks create a no-regrets snacking experience.
$5.49 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 5
David's Cookies Peanut Butter Chunk Fresh-Baked Decadent Cookie Gift Basket Tin — Luscious Large Peanut Butter Cookies With No Added Preservatives — All-Natural Cookies — Ideal Gift for Corporate Birthday Fathers Mothers Day Get Well and Other Special Occasions - 2 lb (8 Cookies)
David's Cookies Peanut Butter Chunk Fresh-Baked Decadent Cookie Gift Basket Tin — Luscious Large Peanut Butter Cookies With No Added Preservatives — All-Natural Cookies — Ideal Gift for Corporate Birthday Fathers Mothers Day Get Well and Other Special Occasions - 2 lb (8 Cookies)
  • Decadent Peanut Butter Cookies: Indulge in luscious, large cookies perfect for any occasion.
  • No Added Preservatives: Enjoy all-natural goodness in every bite, guilt-free indulgence assured.
  • Thoughtful Gift Tin: Impress with a beautifully packaged basket, ideal for various special occasions.
  • Premium Quality Ingredients: Crafted with care, using only the finest ingredients for superior taste.
  • Memorable Gift Idea: Elevate celebrations with this delightful treat, sure to leave a lasting impression.
$33.95 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
SaleBestseller No. 6
Lance Sandwich Cookies, Nekot Peanut Butter, 10 Individually Wrapped Packs, 6 Sandwiches Each
Lance Sandwich Cookies, Nekot Peanut Butter, 10 Individually Wrapped Packs, 6 Sandwiches Each
  • Peanut butter cookies: mildly sweet cookie crackers with real peanut butter filling
  • Real peanut butter: made with real peanut butter we make ourselves
  • Sweet treat: 4g of protein per serving, no high-fructose corn syrup
  • On-the-go snack: try these cookie packs for lunch treats or afternoon, on-the-go snacks
  • 10 cracker packs: box of 10 individual cracker snack packs, 6 sandwich crackers per pack
$3.99 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 7
Amazon Grocery, Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 1 Lb (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)
Amazon Grocery, Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 1 Lb (Previously Happy Belly, Packaging May Vary)
  • One pound package of Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
  • Some of your favorite Happy Belly products are now part of the Amazon Grocery brand! Although packaging may vary during the transition, the ingredients and product remain the same. Thank you for your continued trust in our brands
  • Family Size
  • About 16 servings per package
  • Contains: Peanuts, Soy, Wheat
Buy on Amazon
SaleBestseller No. 8
FITCRUNCH Snack Size Protein Bars, 6-Layer Baked Bar, 1g of Sugar, Gluten Free & Soft Cake Core (9 Bars, Peanut Butter Cookie)
FITCRUNCH Snack Size Protein Bars, 6-Layer Baked Bar, 1g of Sugar, Gluten Free & Soft Cake Core (9 Bars, Peanut Butter Cookie)
  • 16 grams of protein
  • 1 gram of sugar
  • 210 Calories
  • Gluten Free
  • Chef Created
$17.59 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon
Bestseller No. 9
Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 16g Plant Protein, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4 Ounce Cookie (Pack of 12)
Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie, Peanut Butter, Soft Baked, 16g Plant Protein, Vegan, Non-GMO, 4 Ounce Cookie (Pack of 12)
  • BETTER FOR YOU: The Complete Cookie is a tasty and filling choice for a healthier snack option. Soft-baked and Certified Vegan, this cookie is a convenient source of plant-based proteins that taste downright delicious.
  • CERTIFIED VEGAN PROTEIN COOKIE: This snack includes 16g of plant-based protein and 10g of fiber per cookie (4oz)
  • Plant Based Protein: With 16g of plant based proteins and 10g of fiber, The Complete Cookie will not only satisfy your tummy and sweet tooth but also your peace of mind
  • BETTER FOR YOU: The Complete Cookie is a tasty and filling choice for a healthier snack option. Soft-baked and Certified Vegan, this cookie is a convenient source of plant-based proteins that taste downright delicious.
  • 12 Pack: With your order, you will receive a box of 12 delicious 4oz cookies. What are you waiting for? Join in on the YUM
$21.99 Amazon Prime
Buy on Amazon

Best Peanut Butter Cookies Buying Guide

1. Perfect Texture: The perfect texture of a good peanut butter cookie is one that is crisp around the edges and slightly soft in the center.

You can achieve this texture with the perfect amount of leaveners and the right ratio of fats and flour.

2. Low Sugar and Salt: Because peanut butter cookies are naturally sweet, you don’t need much added sugar. You can use brown sugar or granulated sugar with some molasses for depth of flavor.

Also, peanut butter cookies typically use a little salt to balance the sweet, so use a little more than you normally would.

3. Creamy Peanut Butter: Using a creamy peanut butter will help create cookies with a nice, rich, and creamy texture.

4. Texture: You can add chopped up pieces of peanut butter cups, chocolate chips, or add in chopped peanuts for added texture.

5. Right Amount of Dough: You want to use enough dough to roll into a ball, but not so much that the dough is too thick and difficult to roll.

6. Right Shape: When you are making peanut butter cookies, you don’t want them to be too thick because they will spread as they bake.

7. Size: Aim for a size that is smaller than a regular cookie so they are easier to dip in milk.

8. Perfectly Done: To know when your peanut butter cookies are done, use an inserted toothpick. The cookies are done when the toothpick comes out with a few crumbs attached.

9. Underbaked: If you are worried that your cookies are underbaked, you can use a different method.

Instead of using a toothpick, you can check the color of your peanut butter cookies. They are done when the tops are pale and golden brown.


What else you should know about peanut butter cookies

1. What is the best way to store peanut butter cookies?

The best way to store peanut butter cookies is in an airtight container.

2. How can I make my peanut butter cookies more moist?

There are a few things you can do to make your peanut butter cookies more moist. You can add an extra egg to the recipe, add some milk, or add some extra peanut butter. You can also try using a different type of peanut butter, such as natural peanut butter, which is usually more moist than regular peanut butter.

3. Why do my peanut butter cookies spread so much?

There are a few reasons why your peanut butter cookies might be spreading too much. One reason could be that your cookie dough is too soft. If your cookie dough is too soft, it will spread more when it is baking. Another reason could be that your cookies are not being baked long enough. If your cookies are not being baked long enough, they will not be set and will spread more. Finally, if you are using a glass baking dish, your cookies might be spreading more. Glass baking dishes conduct heat differently than metal baking dishes, so your cookies might spread more in a glass dish.

4. How do I keep my peanut butter cookies from sticking to the pan?

There are a few things you can do to keep your peanut butter cookies from sticking to the pan. You can coat the pan with cooking spray or butter before adding the dough. You can also use a silicone baking mat or parchment paper to line the pan.

5. What is the best way to flavor peanut butter cookies?

There are many ways to flavor peanut butter cookies, but some of the most popular include adding chocolate, cinnamon, or even a little bit of salt.


Conclusion

On the market, there are numerous best peanut butter cookies. Hopefully, the list of the top ten best peanut butter cookies will save you time researching and deciding on the best one for you.

Primary Sidebar

Related Posts

  1. Best Renewable Energy Controllers
  2. Best Fire Escape Ladders
  3. Best Carbon Monoxide Detectors
  4. Best Self Defense Pepper Spray
  5. Best Drop Slot Safes
  6. Best Foot Arch Supports
  7. Best Ball Of Foot Cushions
  8. Best Mp3 Player Batteries
  9. Best Internal Frame Hiking Backpacks
  10. Best Instant Film Cameras

Recent Posts

  • Best 16-inch Brushless Cordless Chainsaws
  • Best 10 Cup Rice Cookers
  • Best Smart Watch For Men
  • Best Kitchen Knife Set
  • Best Holiday Gift Baskets
  • Best Bpa Free Electric Kettle
  • Best Family Gift Baskets For Christmas
  • Best Scratchboard Art Materials
  • Best Sculpture Molding Casting Products
  • Best Sculpture Release Agents
  • Best Sculpture Modeling Tools
  • Best Papier Mache Supplies
  • Best Paper Craft Tools
  • Best Card Making Kits
  • Best Leathercraft Lacing Needles
  • Best Sewing Sequin Trim

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Footer

etcly

ETCLY.com is an Internet Web magazine that covers almost every topic you can think of. Technology seems like a wire that runs through our lives.

Learn More →
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Browse

  • Aquarium
  • Bags & Luggage
  • Bathroom
  • Best Tools
  • Bins
  • Brands
  • Business
  • Camera
  • Cat
  • Celebrity News
  • Cleaner
  • Computer
  • Dog
  • Electronics
  • Fashion
  • Food
  • Gaming
  • Garden
  • Health
  • Horse
  • How To Clean
  • Ice
  • Infographic
  • Jewelry
  • Kitchen Appliances
  • Kitchen Knives
  • LED
  • Lifestyle
  • Light
  • Money
  • Music
  • Pet
  • Popular
  • Shoes & Slippers
  • Sports
  • Terrarium
  • Vacuum Cleaners
  • Water
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Etcly.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.

Copyright © 2025 • etcly.com • All Rights Reserved